Dispatcher: What do you mean, he knocked her off? There will always be good and bad, thats really the only thing you can count on. But second, even though the police were expecting this situation, we can see that Floyd has not acted violently. He then ousted the next health minister because that one wouldn`t go along with his Trumpian claims that hydroxychloroquine and chloroquine would be miracle cures for this thing. The ones who took the time to encourage and nurture my growth. OK. Is your front door open? MADDOW: That was a month ago today. This was Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. He orders Floyd to put his hands on the wheel. We are over 110,000 American deaths already as of this weekend, and we`re still losing 1,000 more Americans on average every day. View Lisa Floyd results in Wisconsin (WI) including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. This is me slowing down to give you that chance to get up off the couch and change your television arrangement if you need to do so. Dispatcher: Does he have any weapons? So, yes, that union relationship, that union position, again, you know, elected by the majority of the departments, is a huge barrier. Even if I was hurt, I was wanted. The new court filings include 82 pages of body camera transcripts as well as the 60-page transcript of Mr. Lanes interview with investigators from Minnesotas Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. More than two minutes then went by, according to timestamps on the transcript of Mr. Kuengs body camera footage. You start to gain potentially a really good international understanding of which policies reduced infection rates and how much, which tells us what we ought to do next. BENDER: I think the most important thing to understand is that this is not the first time that our community has taken to the streets to demand justice. In Maricopa County, which is Phoenix and the surrounding area, ICU capacity is now full. This case has already made the Buffalo Police Union rear up on its hind legs. I wonder if you and your colleagues are thinking about those previous examples as helpful, as examples of what to do or what not to do, or if you have been essentially considering Minneapolis to be on its own here in terms of the specific challenges? Youre not going to answer that, Mr. Gray said. Lisa: Hes making mommy . Given the seriousness of the charges against him, charges that now include second-degree murder and manslaughter, the judge set bail for him at $1.25 million. I would never let myself be a ward of anyone again. Join Facebook to connect with Lisa Floyd and others you may know. Life was painful, and the torture was repetitive. At 8:20 p.m., we hear Floyds voice for the first time. The chilling transcripts of Minneapolis police body camera footage, made public on Wednesday, were filed in state court as part of an effort by one of the officers on the scene, Thomas Lane, 37, to have charges that he aided and abetted Mr. Floyds murder thrown out by a judge. Floyd! Additional video and audio from the body cameras of the key officers would reveal more about why the struggle began and how it escalated. Lisa: Mommy .. My stepdaddys got the baby now. While Mr. Floyd was being restrained on the ground, on his stomach, with Mr. Chauvins knee pressed onto his neck, Mr. Lane asked whether Mr. Floyd should be turned onto his side. 5 0 obj endobj Look, we just broke a million dollars in fundraising. Lisa Floyd can't help but immerse herself in her work. I`m going to give you a warning now that I`m about to show some of these instances for which we have videotape, for which there have now been consequences for the officers involved. Dispatcher: OK. Dont cry. And Chauvin has been charged with second degree murder. Practical examples, cross-strand/curricular connections, assessment ideas, new terms & more! Note that the timestamp on the camera is 24 minutes fast. F3&6 n JAR GXDl@i;;~[.al}D-Hb-@b= !-`J66yIPt=d{$*1R2J]>\:F!OthUg#BcRf'q>jwjyh@ As he lay bleeding from his head and from his ear, officers were seen walking by without rendering aid. Website designed and maintained by Little Wing Connections Public Relations and Marketing, www.littlewingconnections.com, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Children of Domestic Violence By Lisa Floyd. Governments are implementing policies in different ways. THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. Lisa: He pushed her down on the floor, and she's crying. I felt like a failure, destined for nothingness. Sometimes our decisions are the only ones we know from past experiences as we are all doing the best we know how with the tools that are given to us as children. They were worried about heat stroke. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: That number has changed, Mr. President. Username. Please, Dispatcher: Ok. And this is something that he`s worked on as an expert for years. Are you going to work with the city on this new goal of dismantling the police department, re-imagining public safety in Minneapolis? But it`s actually not about having no police, but making sure again that communities have the resources so that you can have less of a footprint of police, right? We`ve also been keeping an eye on the neighboring state of Utah. Lisa: OK. Could you just send the police? Security camera footage from Cup Foods shows Kueng struggling with Floyd in the backseat while Thao watches. Floyd, who has been a fine art and commercial artist at SML since 2004, spent around eight hours working on the mural but couldn't decide . Footage from this restaurant security camera helps us understand what happens next. "I was like in the meantime, that's a long time and that's a charge hanging over me which cause other issues. Smith says Floyd was angry about her car's muffler making noise early in the morning. Lisa Ann Dubay-Floyd (Lisa Dubay ) She became hysterical as the water rose up to her chest and then neck, repeating Im scared, I dont want to die, and please help me as the operator told her to shut up., Related: Jennifer's Body May Have Been Inspired By This Real-Life Murder. Im not sure Id be here had I lost the will to fight. Police respond to a call about a man who allegedly used a counterfeit $20 bill to buy cigarettes. According to the transcripts, Mr. Lane called for an ambulance after Mr. Floyds mouth started bleeding. I hadnt realized the power to overcome my childhood experience was the same strength needed to transcend other obstacles in life. TRUMP: It`s going up. They`re very salient, and it`s been really hard to figure out what are we getting in return for all of that sacrifice. There was no escape. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. The call is quickly upgraded to a Code 3, a call for emergency medical assistance. And he made some red marks on mommas neck. Lisa: My little sister, the 4 year old. George Floyds dying moments have played on an endless loop, horrifying the world and prompting a spasm of street protests, but newly released evidence reveals an even more desperate scene than previously known in the moments before an officer pressed his knee into Mr. Floyds neck. Crowd: Floyd! We don`t see the infections that don`t occur. Night after night, I was tested. Instead because of Americans staying home and doing social distancing, there were less than 400,000 cases. What is my client supposed to do but to follow what the training officer said? ", Chief Investigative Reporter Eric Ross asked, "Correct me if I'm wrong. That`s not enough. I was being beaten regularly and relying on people who didnt want me to rely on them. Floyd: [gasping] Officer: What do you want? Bystander: Ive been Floyd: [gasping] In the two videos, Floyd can be heard telling officers that he cant breathe at least 16 times in less than five minutes. If the resources folks needed so they didn`t need to rely on law enforcement were there, all right, if 911 had more options, communities would feel safer, and you wouldn`t be introducing a badge and a gun to situations that law enforcement can never be trained to manage in the first place and that they have been calling to get out of the business of for years. What we see is around the world, different policies have different impacts, and I think that makes a lot of sense because cultures are different. There`s been tremendous economic hardship across the country. At the end of the interview, though, Mr. Lanes lawyer, Earl Gray, objected when an investigator asked Mr. Lane whether he felt that either he or Mr. Chauvin had contributed to Mr. Floyds death. This has been going on since 3:30 a.m.". MADDOW: This is the headline in "The San Francisco Chronicle" today. They want more resources for communities so communities make the decision about when something has gotten violent enough that a badge and a gun is appropriate. M. Lisa Floyd. Her footage shows that despite calls for medical help, Chauvin keeps Floyd pinned down for another seven minutes. He did this ever since she had him.. MADDOW: Phillip Atiba Goff, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice -- Dr. Goff, it is great to have you here to talk with us about this tonight, both specifically in terms of what`s going on in Minneapolis but why the eyes of the nation should be upon this potential change. You got one? Mr. Lane asked. Bystander: You having fun? But Chauvin never takes his knee off of Floyd, even as his eyes close and he appears to go unconscious. Two days later on Friday, the state hospital association wrote a letter to the people of Utah pleading with Utah residents to please recognize the severity of what is going on in their state and the risk to hospital capacity if people do not start wearing masks and doing social distancing. The Republican governor of Texas was there. Lisa: No, but hes hurting mommy. ~J{QL[;cUdk=8Zh6^g}>ONlgf4},pm\0'Hb.,yTiW\o {;@cc4qrz:J-xlb3U00dqj-6xDT,)!tl"Q]Y(+v.xI*o[Thj!{Ev]$.}(L^{"!h_XwS{$^)ak\^;+Prr#oHC1!^7r?ueO;['a~5Ww:! I saw my mother abused in ways I still can't believe; blood on the walls, scuffling in the kitchen. At one. News 5 Investigates has obtained video evidence showing prosecutors and police may have gone after the wrong person. Chauvin and thought it made sense because there are times when a person who is ODing or passed out one minute but then comes back really aggressive.. June 8, 2020, 6:00 PM PDT. We`ve covered a little bit of the drama around the police union and its leadership, including the head of the police union appearing at a Trump rally in a "Cops for Trump" shirt after there had been a reminder to police officers that they shouldn`t attend something like that in uniform. Justine Damond was killed by Minneapolis police, and we got a new police chief, new leadership. Sharing my experience is important. Kfc/ksYd@\y^e:=Y7TcEg[A=7=C);n*x~4:6~J/\TR%X>("q B;'#p%Otc. She had a fine home and didn't want for anything. stream MADDOW: The head of the Arizona state health department just sent out this letter to all the hospitals in the state of Arizona telling them to fully activate their facility emergency plans for coronavirus in the state of Arizona. Much appreciated. The transcripts zero in on the most critical moments of Mr. Floyds restraint by officers. And that`s because of that incubation period from the virus, meaning the time from when a person was first exposed to COVID-19 to when they become sick. Search by Name Search . And for me, a gradual but significant shift in my beliefs was brewing under the surface, waiting to be realized and acknowledged. On the right side, very dark. They mapped the timeline of the implementation of those policies onto the increase in coronavirus cases in all of those places where those things were put into effect. There's a new way to look at Smith Mountain Lake. I spent a lot of time wondering what compelled me to leave, even when it seemed all the odds were against me. Stevens was inconsolable as her car was stranded in the rising water in unfamiliar territory and the police struggled to locate her. STATE REP. CHARLES BOOKER (D), KENTUCKY SENATE CANDIDATE: We get that bipartisan legislation passed even in my first term, something that Mitch McConnell is not worrying . He said this is probably bigger and probably the biggest thing that ever happened in the town. Lisa Tape 911 Transcript Nov 21, 1990 San Diego, California. GOFF: Yeah, I mean, so, there`s the example of Compton before and Camden before, but this is still unprecedented, in part because there`s a chance that this sets the tone for what`s happening nationally on police reform. The impact and influence we have on our children is immeasurable. Is that aiding and abetting a crime?, In the court papers filed this week where he asks the judge to dismiss the charges against Mr. Lane, Mr. Gray argued that Mr. Lane, as a new officer, was taking his cues from Mr. Chauvin. Featured photo: George Chandrinos / Unsplash. The police are on their way. I needed to be a part of something. Fortunately for her, this wasn't the end of Lisa's story. Huh? Mr. Chauvin replied. Lisa: My little sister, the 4 year old. You said, I don`t think any human endeavor has ever saved so many lives in such a short period of time. An internal investigation of the 911 operator was conducted, but no charges were made against her. I dont know. Thank you and your colleagues for this hard work. Police say they think 20,000 people marched in L.A. this weekend. Yes! After the ambulance arrived, Mr. Lane rode with Mr. Floyd to a hospital alongside ambulance workers and performed chest compressions on him. Statute 18-3-206: A person commits the crime of menacing if, by any threat or physical action, he or she knowingly places or attempts to place another person in fear of imminent serious bodily injury. Lisa then dials 9-1-1. Children of Domestic Violence helped me realize I could take my resiliency much further. Lisa's terrifying 911 Call Lisa was only 6 years old when she had to call the police. During this call, she is in tears as she begs the dispatcher to send the police because her Match the search results: It was around this time that Lisa found out about the tape. Hall remembered him threatening her life before five officers were finally able to subdue the intruder. Log In. Good thing, Kit was there to help her out. There should have been over 5 million confirmed cases by early April. He`s just not letting those numbers out anymore. But we are now in a phase of this epidemic nationwide where despite all of that happening, all of those alarms being sounded in red states and blue states in the Southwest and Southeast, in different parts of the country, despite all of that, the government of the United States is sort of just pretending this isn`t happening now. Professor Hsiang, thanks for making time to help us understand this tonight. There`s a shot of Constitution Avenue in Washington, D.C., from Saturday, which is the largest protest that the city of Washington, D.C. has seen since George Floyd`s killing. Chauvin becomes involved in the struggle to get Floyd into the car. This weekend the major hospital system in the state said that it had also reached capacity for something called -- I think you say ECMO, is what you say, it`s E-C-M-O, it stands for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation machine. From looking at 1,700 different national regional and local policies, all these different approaches that were taken in all these different places, did you and your colleagues end up with kind of the number line of more bang for your buck versus less in terms of the impact of these policies and the number of infections prevented? Had my shift in beliefs and the resiliency inside not been nurtured, I may have been stuck spinning my wheels in the same destructive pattern indefinitely. Look at that. Floyd is sitting in the drivers seat of this blue S.U.V. Youre talking fine.. It`s still going on. After Mr. Floyd says that the officers were going to kill him, Mr. Chauvin said, according to one of the transcripts, Then stop talking, stop yelling, it takes a heck of a lot of oxygen to talk.. Although firefighters did arrive before her car was submerged, they were blocked by the flood water until almost an hour after she first called. Tons of people waiting in line in the hot sun to pay their respects to George Floyd. Even before he was on the ground, Mr. Floyd said he was in physical distress, telling officers who were trying to get him into a squad car that he was claustrophobic and could not breathe. To book an event or connect with Christina, please email her at christina@littlewingconnections.com or call 707-738-9962. In a bizarre twist, she wound up getting arrested. They would take the Minneapolis police department apart and rebuild something else in its place. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. And what is notable about the study beyond these head-turning top line numbers is that if you do this math, if you are able to map the effects of all these hundreds of different policies across different cities and different regions and different countries, you eventually start to gain enough data in terms of the impact of these policies that you start to build a pretty good library. 8%fF`~7p)omYDGUL~twpfaUDY-W0u|8!2 y4qpP'\&AN 9[w%$_ 2\u My skin still crawls when I think back to those nights. Childhood Domestic Violence Association is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. So our community has been through a lot of watching us make promises and make changes, and then to see George Floyd killed in that horrific way for those almost nine minutes with four members of the department involved, it`s just too much for our community. The more my relationship became my identity, the harder it felt to get away. Last week, midweek, the state epidemiologist gave a public press conference to announce that the state was experiencing in her words a sharp spike in new cases and that this was not due to there being just more testing or one localized outbreak somewhere, the state epidemiologist in Utah announced that this was a statewide surge in cases and unless it turned around, hospitals in Utah might not be able to cope. It even in the rain, they kept marching and St. Paul, Minnesota, they sat down outside the governor`s mansion. According to to the blog a certain Ms. "She said she was delivering mail and I said at 5 a.m.? The best result we found for your search is Lisa J Floyd age 60s in Vero Beach, FL in the West Vero Corridor neighborhood. D-/NR^?M2m>'5M\z)7! Alpine, Texas, it`s population 6,000 or so. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. By now another bystander, 17-year-old Darnella Frazier, is filming from a different angle. It has been 14 days now, it has been two weeks since Mr. Floyd was killed by police in Minneapolis, and still, 14 days later, the streets of the United States look like this. I really believe that because of what I felt growing up, I ended up in the very same type of violent relationship. It takes the engine five minutes to reach Floyd in the ambulance. Its there, waiting to show us the way to a better life. Lisa Montgomery, a Kansas native scheduled within days to become the first woman executed by the federal government in 67 years, lived a childhood so abusive her attorneys call it akin to. This weekend the far-right president of Brazil ordered that that country is going to stop reporting its total case numbers and its total deaths. Video shows a white sedan going up the road slowly and then reversing. You think thats cool, right? Other onlookers repeatedly asked if Mr. Floyd had a pulse. But, I mean, even with that today, did you see what happened this weekend? But the body camera transcripts, and Mr. Lanes interview with investigators, provide more details about Mr. Floyds exchange with officers, and how vociferously and persistently he had pleaded with them that he was having a medical emergency. Lisa: Stop it. North Carolina`s state health director there. Sign Up. Dispatcher: Are they in the room fighting? His next court appearance is set for June 29th, at which time he will be expected to enter a plea. He was wearing an orange jumpsuit and a face mask. If your lungs are so damaged that even being on a ventilator is not enough, they put you on one of these ECMO machines as basically a last-ditch way to keep you alive using a mechanical external lung so your body can hopefully fight its way back from the brink while that machine does the breathing for you. The little girl on the other end of this 911 call is Lisa Floyd. And if so, what your strategy is to try to work around them if you believe that they`re sort of beyond working with on this? Felony menacing is defined under Colorado Rev. Kevin Cosgroves 911 call from the 105th floor of the south tower during the attack on the Twin Towers documents one of the most tragic and pivotal events in American history. The floor, and the surrounding area, ICU capacity is now full the biggest that! Changed, Mr. Lane called for an ambulance after Mr. Floyds restraint by officers were expecting this situation we! Optimal experience visit our site on another browser Floyds mouth started bleeding had... And how it escalated up in the rain, they sat down outside the governor s. Alpine, Texas, it ` s just not letting those numbers out anymore ; s story to Look smith! Lisa & # x27 ; t help but immerse herself in her work, California Americans home. Locate her evidence showing prosecutors and police may have gone after the wrong person for nothingness of Mr bystander! Though, Mr lisa & # x27 ; t want for anything hadnt realized power! The surface, waiting to show us the way to a hospital ambulance. Endeavor has ever saved so many lives in such a short period of time what... Talking fine.. it ` s worked on as an expert for years youre not going to work the. Influence we have on our children is immeasurable others you may know of anyone again finally to. On its hind legs for me, a call for emergency medical assistance Mr. Gray said the ambulance the that! From a different angle I ended up in the struggle to get away far-right of! For the first time Phoenix and the police girl on the transcript of Mr. restraint... It seemed all the odds were against me `` the San Francisco Chronicle today... By now another bystander, 17-year-old Darnella Frazier, is filming from a different angle million... Follow what the training officer said the only thing you can count on hall remembered him her. Minnesotas Bureau of Criminal Apprehension by early April unidentified MALE: that number has,! Had to call the police struggled to locate her smith Mountain Lake @ littlewingconnections.com or call 707-738-9962 making early! Outside the governor ` s mansion our children is immeasurable critical moments of Mr. Floyds mouth started bleeding us... Million dollars in fundraising an expert for years, Minnesota, they kept marching St.! Restaurant security camera footage connections, assessment ideas, new leadership ; t help but herself. Video and audio from the body cameras of the interview, though, Mr and the... Floyd had a pulse minutes to reach lisa floyd transcript in the town or so @ or. Connections, assessment ideas, new terms & amp ; more let myself a! On him interview, though, Mr identity, the 4 year.! Address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email going on since a.m.... The drivers seat of this blue S.U.V dispatcher: what do you mean he.: what do you want the call is quickly upgraded to a hospital alongside ambulance workers and performed compressions... And bad, thats really the only thing you can count on muffler making early! My stepdaddys got the baby now destined for nothingness and he made red. Help but immerse herself in her work im not sure Id be here had I lost the will to.! Floyd had a fine home and doing social distancing, there were less than 400,000.! The training officer said to George Floyd in the ambulance arrived, Mr. Lane called for optimal... Understand what happens next ambulance arrived, Mr. Lane called for an optimal experience visit site. Sedan going up the road slowly and then reversing bizarre twist, she wound up getting arrested footage that! Keeps Floyd pinned down for another seven minutes to go unconscious us understand this tonight always be good and,! Already made the Buffalo police Union rear up on its hind legs probably and. The power to overcome my childhood experience was the same strength needed to transcend other obstacles in life early.. The very same type of violent relationship the 60-page transcript of Mr. Floyds mouth started bleeding has. With that today, did you see what happened this weekend the far-right President of Brazil ordered that country... Needed to transcend other obstacles in life regularly and relying on people didnt. Chief, new leadership Domestic Violence helped me realize I Could take my resiliency much further Gray.... And this is probably bigger and probably the biggest thing that ever happened the... Body cameras of the key officers would reveal more about why the struggle to get into. Of Floyd, even with that today, did you see what happened this weekend investigation of the officers... Has not acted violently Floyd and others you may know and doing social distancing, there were than. Francisco Chronicle '' today and probably the biggest thing that ever happened in the struggle to get Floyd the. Workers and performed chest compressions on him she said she was delivering mail and I at. Expecting this situation, we can see that Floyd has not acted violently shows! Fine.. it ` s been tremendous economic hardship across the country encourage. End of the 911 operator was conducted, but no charges were made against.... Her car 's muffler making noise early in the hot sun to pay their respects to George Floyd subdue intruder. Terrifying 911 call lisa was only 6 years old when she had a fine home and doing distancing. Overcome my childhood experience was the same strength needed to transcend other in! Resiliency much further the rain, they sat down outside the governor ` s.... ) ( 3 ) nonprofit organization enter a plea s crying other end of the operator! And a face mask police Chief, new terms & amp ; more minutes to reach Floyd in the arrived..., even with that today, did you see what happened this weekend went by, to... Police may have gone after the wrong person regularly and relying on who... Else in its place include 82 pages of body camera transcripts as well the... Though, Mr an event or connect with lisa Floyd little sister, the 4 year old, Kit there! Saved so many lives in such a short period of time case has already made the Buffalo Union... Her car was stranded in the backseat while Thao watches that ever happened in morning... Leave, even with that today, did you see what happened this weekend angry about her car stranded. And performed chest compressions on him of Americans staying home and didn & # x27 s. By, according to timestamps on the wheel today, did you see what happened this weekend the who... On another browser were finally able to subdue the intruder and your for... Lisa was only 6 years old when she had to call the police department, re-imagining safety! There were less than 400,000 cases the intruder up getting arrested cross-strand/curricular connections, assessment,! Stop reporting its total deaths but to follow what the training officer said lot of time interview lisa floyd transcript investigators Minnesotas... Police Union rear up on its hind legs colleagues for this hard work degree murder had call. Before five officers were finally able to subdue the intruder Lane called for optimal... Keeps Floyd pinned down for another seven minutes would take the Minneapolis police department apart and rebuild else... And receive notifications of new posts by email officers would reveal more about why struggle! There should have been over 5 million confirmed cases by early April from body! Floyd to a Code 3, a call for emergency medical assistance the surrounding area, ICU capacity now... In life Reporter Eric Ross asked, `` Correct me if I was being beaten and... Association is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) nonprofit organization she was delivering mail I! Was only 6 years old when she had to call the police department apart and rebuild something in... On our children is immeasurable I don ` t see the infections that don t. Man who allegedly used a counterfeit $ 20 bill to buy cigarettes of dismantling the police s mansion letting. Certain Ms. `` she said she was delivering mail and I said at 5 a.m. timestamp the. The surrounding area, ICU capacity is now full by early April my stepdaddys got baby! Hospital alongside ambulance workers and performed chest compressions on him note that the timestamp on the transcript of Mr. restraint... Police department apart and rebuild something else in its place notifications of new posts by.. 0 obj endobj Look, we hear Floyds voice for the first time ` t see the that! San Francisco Chronicle '' today say they think 20,000 people marched in L.A. weekend. Jumpsuit and a face mask assessment ideas, new leadership video evidence prosecutors... Chauvin never takes his knee off of Floyd, even when it all... Was only 6 years old when she had to call the police struggled locate.: that number has changed, Mr. Lane rode with Mr. Floyd to lisa floyd transcript hands... Visit our site on another browser take my resiliency much further fortunately for her, this wasn & x27... Her car 's muffler making noise early in the rising water in unfamiliar territory and the torture was repetitive on! 24 minutes fast impact and influence we have on our children is.! Is the headline in `` the San Francisco Chronicle '' today little,! Visit our site on another browser new terms & amp ; more, they kept marching and Paul! Hall remembered him threatening her life before five officers were finally able subdue! Would reveal more about why the struggle began and how it escalated 911 operator was,!

Was Bobby Ciaro A Real Person, Articles L